Skip to content
Vinyl Me, Please

AI search teardown

How Vinyl Me, Please added 49 Google AI Overview citations in six months.

Vinyl Me, Please sells a vinyl record club, with exclusive pressings delivered monthly to collectors. In six months Google’s AI Overviews went from about 6 citations of vinylmeplease.com to 55, though AI answers across all engines fell by 143 to 115, and ChatGPT names it first among vinyl record subscription clubs in the US. We looked at the pages that earn those citations.

Company
Vinyl Me, Please, vinylmeplease.com
Category
Vinyl record subscription
Data
May to November 2026
Written by
Shahab Ahmed

Independent analysis. Vinyl Me, Please is not a Devziv client.

Get your AI audit today

The Vinyl Me, Please homepage, vinylmeplease.com, on 19 November 2026
+49Google AI Overview citations in six months, now 55
1stpick in ChatGPT’s top 3 vinyl record subscription clubs in the US
+528referring domains in six months, now 3.9K
115AI answers citing the site across all engines, down 143

Ahrefs Site Explorer, United States, May to November 2026, and ChatGPT, November 2026.

Google AI Overviews citing Vinyl Me, Please

+49

in six months, to 55 in November 2026. In May it was about 6.

Perplexity
24
Google AI Mode
18
ChatGPT
11
0204060about 655May 2026November 2026

Where it started: AI Overviews barely cited Vinyl Me, Please.

People choosing a record club ask very specific questions: which vinyl subscription is best, which pressings are worth paying for, whether a club delivers what it promised. More of those questions now get answered by Google’s AI Overviews before anyone clicks a result.

In May 2026 those AI Overviews cited vinylmeplease.com about 6 times (55 now, minus the 49 gained). Organic traffic went the other way: 5,722 a month in the week of 18 May and 4,723 in the week of 9 November, down 17%. Organic keywords fell by 44 to 128, and keywords in Google’s top three by 4 to 88.

Ahrefs performance chart for vinylmeplease.com, May to November 2026. Week of 9 to 13 November selected.
  • AOrganic traffic: 4,723 a month.
Ahrefs Site Explorer, United States, changes over the last six months. Week of 9 to 13 November 2026.
Ahrefs performance chart for vinylmeplease.com, May to November 2026. Week of 18 to 24 May selected.
  • AOrganic traffic: 5,722 a month.
Ahrefs Site Explorer, United States, changes over the last six months. Week of 18 to 24 May 2026.

What Vinyl Me, Please does that AI engines pick up.

  • A plain notice about its new owner. The homepage carries a dated notice, “03 JUNE 2025 — MAJOR NEWS VNYL INC ACQUIRES VINYL ME, PLEASE (VMP)”, linking to a news page. That page says VMP is “relaunching under new ownership following its acquisition by VNYL Inc., the direct-to-consumer music company behind VinylBox and the VNYL brand”, and that it “in recent years struggled with fulfillment delays, operational breakdowns, and unmet customer expectations.” VNYL is the second pick in ChatGPT’s answer, and its line on VMP mentions “its past fulfillment issues”.
  • A public list of promises kept. A “Promises Kept” section, on the homepage and on its own page, lists “Projects started under the previous VMP, finished and shipped under new ownership.” There are eight records, from Fela Kuti’s The Best of the Black President to Willie Colón’s El Malo, each with its VMP number and album code. A link, “See the status of every inherited project”, points to a Google Sheets spreadsheet.
  • Pressing details up front. Each record on the homepage says how it was made: “4xLP 180g / lacquers by Cicely Balston” for the Fela Kuti box set, “mastered at abbey road” for fakemink, “2xLP 180 gram ‘bloodshed’, hand-numbered” for N.W.A. ChatGPT’s answer leads with the same strength: “Premium exclusive pressings, collectible editions”.
  • A story behind each featured record. The homepage links to a story page for three records: Fela Kuti, N.W.A. and Max Roach. The Max Roach page, for a “65th Anniversary VMP Exclusive” of We Insist! cut by Ryan Smith at Sterling Sound, carries an essay by Ashawnta Jackson on Abbey Lincoln: “She Was Called the Black Marilyn Monroe. She Had Other Ideas.”
  • More sites link to it. Referring domains rose by 528 to 3.9K in the same six months, and backlinks by 4.2K to 31.4K (Ahrefs). Domain Rating stayed at 70.

Where Vinyl Me, Please gets cited now.

  • AI answers citing vinylmeplease.com went from about 258 to 115 in six months, across all engines.
  • Google AI Overviews account for 55 of them, up 49. The number of Vinyl Me, Please pages they cite rose by 9, to 13.
  • Google AI Mode cites it in 18 answers, up 2, and Copilot in 4.
  • Perplexity cites it far less than six months ago: 24 answers, down 154. ChatGPT fell by 18 to 11, Gemini by 18 to 3, and Grok, now paused, by 4. Pages cited across all engines fell by 196, to 38.
EngineShareResponsesSix monthsPages cited
Google AI Overviews5549 up over six months13 9 up over six months
Google AI Mode182 up over six months9 4 down over six months
ChatGPT1118 down over six months5 30 down over six months
Gemini318 down over six months2 16 down over six months
Perplexity24154 down over six months23 134 down over six months
Copilot42 1 down over six months
Grok (paused)04 down over six months0 21 down over six months
Ahrefs overview for vinylmeplease.com, US, November 2026: 115 AI responses, -143 in six months.
  • AGoogle AI Overviews: 55 responses, up 49 in six months.
  • BGoogle AI Mode: 18 responses, up 2.
Ahrefs Site Explorer, United States, changes over the last six months, captured November 2026.

ChatGPT names Vinyl Me, Please first among vinyl record subscription clubs.

In a ChatGPT answer listing the top 3 vinyl record subscription clubs in the US, captured in November 2026, Vinyl Me, Please is named first. Only the last line of the question is in the capture.

It answered: “Vinyl Me, Please (VMP) — Best overall: Premium exclusive pressings, collectible editions, and excellent genre variety; worth considering despite its past fulfillment issues.”

ChatGPT, US, November 2026: an answer that names Vinyl Me, Please.
  • AVinyl Me, Please is named first, as best overall, and ChatGPT’s closing pick is “Vinyl Me, Please for serious collectors”.
ChatGPT, United States, November 2026. The box around Vinyl Me, Please is from the original capture.

Questions about this teardown.

01Why do Google’s AI Overviews cite Vinyl Me, Please?

Its pages answer a few questions directly: how each record was pressed, the story behind it, who owns the club now and which inherited projects have shipped. Ahrefs counts 13 vinylmeplease.com pages cited in Google’s AI Overviews, up 9. Answer engines quote pages that answer the question asked.

02Did ChatGPT cite Vinyl Me, Please more as well?

No. Ahrefs counts 11 ChatGPT answers citing vinylmeplease.com, 18 fewer than six months earlier, and Perplexity fell by 154 to 24. Across all engines the total fell by 143 to 115; only Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode grew. ChatGPT still names Vinyl Me, Please first in the answer captured for this teardown.

03Is Vinyl Me, Please a Devziv client?

No. This is an independent teardown built from public data: Ahrefs, ChatGPT and Vinyl Me, Please’s own website. Vinyl Me, Please did not take part.

04Can Devziv find out which AI answers cite my business?

Yes. Send us the questions your buyers ask. We run them through the main AI assistants and show you who gets cited, and why.

How we got this data.

  • AI citations, keywords, links and traffic: Ahrefs Site Explorer, United States, changes over the last six months, captured in November 2026. Numbers are copied as Ahrefs prints them, rounded above 1,000.
  • “About 6” in May and “about 258” across all engines are worked out from the six-month change, so they are approximate. The 17% traffic fall compares the two weekly readings in the Ahrefs chart.
  • ChatGPT answer: one question asked in the United States in November 2026; only its last line is in the capture. Answers vary by wording, day and account.
  • Vinyl Me, Please’s pages: read on vinylmeplease.com on 19 November 2026, from its homepage, its Promises Kept page, its news page on the VNYL acquisition and its Max Roach story page.
  • Vinyl Me, Please is not a Devziv client and did not take part.

Want your business
cited in AI answers?

Get your AI audit today. Tell us the questions your buyers ask, and we will show you who gets cited.

Get your AI audit today
CONTACT US

Let’s talk!

✓ Plans from $999 a month✓ Month to month✓ No setup fee✓ 20-question free AI check

What our customers say

Devziv · 30 min meetingCHOOSE A TIME THAT WORKS FOR YOUOpen calendar in a new tab